Reference :- The Sky News anchors are quivering with excitement over Michael Moore's new documentary, " Planet of the Humans ". They see it as confirmation that the fossil fuel industry is actually doing us a great service .
There has been a lot of talk here , in Kooralya , about the controversial documentary that Michael Moore has given the world , gratis , on You Tube . People who describe themselves as "leftist " are displeased , claiming that he unfairly misrepresented the downside of renewable energy proliferation . Those on the "right " gleefully see confirmation of their view that fossil fuels are mankind's greatest asset .
Out here in Kooralya , we don't accept the usual " left vs right " political modelling . My son , Ken junior , reckons it's a remnant from the old cold war , which itself was riddled with misinformation and propaganda . He reckons that model is as obsolete as an 8 track tape player , about as clunky, and similarly useless for playing anything newly released .
Even Monte ( the motorcyclist ) refuses to identify as either left or right politically . He talks about something he calls " the common good " , which he claims is free of ideology and rooted in calm pragmatism . He reckons the concept is all there in his cherished book " Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance " by Robert M Pirsig . His favourite quote from the book is " If you get careless with scientific information , nature will make a complete fool of you . "
And Gabbo ( the aborigine ) reckons the common good concept does not only apply to mankind , but also includes every living creature , and all the trees and mountains and rivers and so on .
Well they are idealistic young chaps , and I applaud them for that idealism .
Personally , I have a more sombre philosophy . I call it " Everything we do has a downside , and we are always slow to discover it " . We raise life expectancies , but that fills nursing homes with suffering old folk. We have our amalgam fillings drilled out because they might be harmful , only to discover that the white plastic fillings are even more toxic. We get divorced because marriage involves too many compromises , only to find that life post- divorce involves even more compromises . We take the lead out of petrol, and then discover that unleaded petrol is more polluting and carcinogenic . And so it goes .
Michael Moore has merely pointed out the obvious , which is that renewable energy production has plenty of downsides . Both the environmentalists he has upset , and the fossil fuel advocates he has pleased are guilty of the same arrogance . They believe that mankind can hugely manipulate nature without adverse consequences , as long it is done the right way . They merely argue about what constitutes " the right way " to get the energy that we greedily demand .
And , as Monte would point out , nature is making complete fools of us .
Your comrade , Ken
No comments:
Post a Comment